Looking for thrift stores in Islip, New York? Our directory lists 2 secondhand stores, consignment shops, and resale boutiques in the Islip area. 2 stores have a phone number listed, 2 have a website, and 2 include posted business hours. Each listing includes the address and a direct link to Google Maps for easy directions.
Whether you're searching for vintage clothing, furniture, books, or household items at a fraction of retail prices, Islip's thrift stores offer affordable alternatives to buying new. Browse the listings below to find a store near you.
2
Stores
2
With Phone
2
With Website
2
With Hours
📍 350 Main St, Islip, NY 11751
📞 +1 631-581-7991
Islip UMC Thrift Shoppe in Islip, New York, offers a cozy spot for thrifters seeking a variety of used goods. Shoppers can discover everything from clothing to home goods, and even unique collectibles that add character to any space. Patrons enjoy the convenience of a wheelchair accessible parking lot and the option for free parking, making quick visits easy and hassle-free.
📍 754 Montauk Hwy, Islip, NY 11751
📞 +1 631-581-4950
St. Mark's Thrift Shop in Islip, New York, offers a delightful treasure trove of used goods, featuring clothing, home goods, and a variety of collectibles that are sure to pique the interest of thrift enthusiasts. Patrons can discover unique items like vintage textiles, intriguing books, and charming retro decor, all waiting for new homes. Shoppers love the shop's quick visit experience, complemented by its wheelchair-accessible entrance and parking, making it an inviting destination for all. Don't forget to bring cash, as this cash-only establishment makes for a straightforward and hassle-free shopping trip.
Join our free newsletter for weekly updates on new store openings, exclusive deals, and thrifting tips from across the country.
No spam, ever. Unsubscribe anytime.