Looking for thrift stores in Bay Shore, New York? Our directory lists 2 secondhand stores, consignment shops, and resale boutiques in the Bay Shore area. 2 stores have a phone number listed, 2 have a website, and 2 include posted business hours. Each listing includes the address and a direct link to Google Maps for easy directions.
Whether you're searching for vintage clothing, furniture, books, or household items at a fraction of retail prices, Bay Shore's thrift stores offer affordable alternatives to buying new. Browse the listings below to find a store near you.
2
Stores
2
With Phone
2
With Website
2
With Hours
📍 1601 5th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
📞 +1 631-666-6207
Hidden Treasures Thrift Shop in Bay Shore, New York, is a charming destination for thrift enthusiasts seeking unique finds. This inviting store boasts a diverse selection of used goods, including stylish clothing, intriguing collectibles, and delightful home goods that keep shoppers coming back for more. With a wheelchair accessible entrance and free parking garage, patrons appreciate the convenience of their shopping experience, making quick visits a breeze. Whether you're on the hunt for vintage treasures or everyday essentials, this shop is sure to surprise and delight.
📍 500 S Country Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706
📞 +1 631-665-0051
St Peter's By the Sea Thrift Shop in Bay Shore, New York, is a welcoming destination for thrifters seeking great finds. This charming shop features a variety of used clothing along with unique home goods, making it a perfect spot for those on the hunt for affordable treasures. Patrons love the convenience of its wheelchair accessible parking lot, ensuring a quick and easy visit for everyone. Whether you're searching for a stylish outfit or a quirky home accent, this thrift shop has something for everyone.
Join our free newsletter for weekly updates on new store openings, exclusive deals, and thrifting tips from across the country.
No spam, ever. Unsubscribe anytime.